This updated list which we came to know as "The Big Logging List" was posted on www.sydney.indymedia.org.au
19th March 2003 for NSW voters to view before the election.
[Better late than never! So Bob Carr has created
330 new national parks. Many are mere patches. To get a balanced view of Carr's policies on woodchipping and logging here
is a Big List of forests he has logged or damaged in the last 8 years. There are additional comments on other natural areas
damaged. The list is incomplete. ]
Further to the anouncement by ecology action sydney (eas) on 30th December 2002 to compile a list of NSW community
forests destroyed or seriously damaged here is a progress report. The final version will be promoted in independent media
in the lead up to the state election on March 22, 2003.
1. Limited response from State Forests of NSW for logging
history in areas across NSW via Harriet of ChipStop and via The Wilderness Society. For instance no data from SF for 1996-2000
in large parts of north east, central and western divisions. These have been woven in to the Big List of logged forest at
2A. "I still have ringing in my ears the (broken) promise by Bob Carr ... to end woodchipping by
2000" Ian Cohen Green MP speech at environment election forum in Sydney 12th March 2003.
But the indications
were there much earlier, refer
"Old forests axed from logging ban" Simon Benson Daily Telegraph 22/11/96 quoting Craig Darlington of South
East Forest Conservation Council (Canberra) "Bob Carr promised to end export woodchipping in NSW by the year 2000.
If that is indeed true this is certainly the wrong way to go about it."
2D. Major funding development in govt policy on landclearing announced last Saturday 11th March with $120
million to create fundamental change in rampant legal and illegal agricultural clearing at 100K hectares a year. Main credit
goes to The Wilderness Society high profile electioneering. Soured by history of govt failures to date see point 5 below.
3. Big List (100 minimum)of forest logged/seriously damaged from community reports and State Forest records released
(forest name, year of logging, info source respectively).
It can now be revealed (Jan 2008) that the major source of the state forest logging records was David Burgess
- famous around this time for his protest with Will Saunders on top the Opera House in early 2003 against the Iraq War - who
obtained them in confidential discussions with the NSW State Forests government agency on behalf of his then employer The
Wilderness Society in Sydney. Thus this big logging list is well referenced. We presume Dave sent them to ecology
action Australia because of his frustration with official channels and mainstream ngo green group effectiveness (?).
Or maybe he just thought he would go to gaol? Dave Burgess now works post conviction for the world famous Opera House
stunt for mainsteam Total Environment Centre.
Even so this list is not exhaustive given time constraints and lack of co-operation from govt in 2002-3, and
does not account for all other natural areas also damaged during this Govt tenure:
- Avon River SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Badja SF, 2001-2, 1996 ecology action
sydney photos, The Wilderness Society literature, State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Bagawa SF 2002, State Forests
via reputable source 2003
- Bald Knob SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Bebo SF 2001, State
Forests via reputable source 2003
- Bangadilly SF 1996, State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Barradine SF 2002,
State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Barrington Tops SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
Beaury SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Bellangry SF 2002 NEFA media release 8/5/02
2000, 2002 State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Biddon SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
SF, 1996-2002 State Forests via ChipStop 2003, Steve Ryan TWS 7/1/00
- Bolaro SF, 1998 Steve Ryan TWS email 7/1/00,
State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Boyne SF 1996-2001 State Forests via Chipstop 2003
- Brother SF 2002, State
Forests via reputable source 2003
- Bulahdelah SF 1998 TWS 16/12/98 media release
- Bungawalbin State Forest,
2000/1, Richmond Environment Network email, NEFA media release 29/3/01.
- Bungabbee SF 2001, NEFA media release 29/3/01
- Buckenbowra SF TWS Wildernews 1999, 2000 (imminent, and refers to 13 other forests at risk), State Forests via ChipStop
- Campbell SF 2001, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Chaelundi SF 2002, compartments 170, 185-7,
190, 192-3 State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Chichester SF 2001-2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Cobbora SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Colymea SF 1996 State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Conglomerate SF, 2000-2, Richmond Environment Network email, NEFA flyer, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Copeland SF 2001, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Conjola SF 1996, State Forests via ChipStop
- Clouds Creek - see Conglomerate
- Cumbil SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
Currambene SF 2002, State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Currowan SF, 1998, 2000, 2002 State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Clyde SF, 1996 State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Dampier SF, 1996-2002, TWS email 7/1/00, ecology action
photos, State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Denobollie SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Etoo SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
Ewingar SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Flat Rock SF 2002 State Forests via ChipStop 2003
Gibberagee SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Gladstone SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source
- Glenugie SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Goonoo SF 2002, State Forests via reputable
- Irishman SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Kangaroo River SF 1999, NEFA media
release 9/7/99 ("Labor's 1995 Forestry Policy has been dishonoured and subverted ...." Suzi Russel, John Corkhill)
Leard SF 2001, State Forest via reputable source 2003
- Lincoln SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
McDonald SF 2002, State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- McPherson SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
Meryla SF 1998 State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Manly Dam forest, Sydney 1998-9, Green Left Weekly 30/6/99 at p2
- Marengo State Forest, 2001 NSW forest networker email, The Advocate p5 23/8/01
- Minnon SF 2002, State Forests
via reputable source 2003
- Mogo SF, 1996-2002 State Forests via ChipStop 2003, Steve Ryan TWS email 7/1/00
Monga SF, 2001-2, ecology action photos, TWS, SEFA media release 18/8/01
- Moruya SF 1996, 1997, 1998, 2002 State
Forests via ChipStop 2003, 1999 Steve Ryan TWS email 7/1/00
- Myall Lakes SF 2000-1, ecology action photos, TWS Sydney
- Myall River State Forest 1999-2002 20-23/2/01 p3, p16, p2, p7/8 Newcastle Herald quoting The Wilderness
Society, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Nambucca SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
North Brooman, 1998, 2002 Steve Ryan, TWS email 7/1/00, State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Oakwood SF 2003, State Forests
via reputable source 2003
- Olney SF 2001-2, TWS Newcastle email, State Forests via reputable source 2003, State Forests
via reputable source 2003
- Ourimbah SF (Watagans/Jilliby Reserve proposal), 1999-2002, NEFA leaflet)
East State Forest 20/3/01 The Advocate page 3 quoting Coffs Conservation Alliance
- Orara West 2001, State Forests
via reputable source 2003
- Peak Alone SF 2000, ecology action photos
- Pilliga SF, Jim Tedder North Coast
Environment Council 19/8/96
- Pilliga East SF 2001-2002 State Forests via reputable source 2003
West SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Pine Creek SF, 2001, Native Forest Network (re koala habitat)
letter, RIC mr
- Scotchman SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Sheas Nob SF, 2001, Clarence
Environment Centre news clipping, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Sherwood SF , 2000, Richmond Environment
Network email, NEFA flyer
- South Brooman, 1996-2002, State Forests via ChipStop 2003, Steve Ryan TWS email 7/1/00
- Shallow Crossing SF 1997, 2002 State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Stewarts Brook SF 2001, State Forests via
reputable source 2003
- Stroud Mountain - see Myall River SF
- Tallaganda SF 1996-2002 Steve Ryan TWS email
7/1/00, 2002 State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Terry Hie Hie 2001, State Forests via reputable source 2003
Timbarra Plateau and forest (clearing, blasting for gold mine), 1997-2001, various sources
- Tomerong SF 1996 State
Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Tomago clearing koala habitat Newcastle Herald 5/1/96, Daily Telegraph
SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Trinkey SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
Tuckers Knob SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Viewmont SF 2002, State Forests via reputable source
- Wandella SF, 1996-2002, ecology action sydney, TWS email 7/1/00, State Forests via ChipStop 2003
Wandera SF 1996, State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Watagans - see Olney, Ourimbah, Wyong SF
- Wang Wauk SF
2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Way Way SF (reference?)
- Wild Cattle Creek State Forest 1996,
2002 over from 1995, NEFA media, letter 9/11/95, NEFA media release 7/7/95, State Forests via reputable source 2003
Wingello SF 1996, 1997 State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Woodenbong 2002, State Forests via reputable source 2003
- Wyong SF, (Watagans/Jilliby Reserve proposal), 1999-2002, NEFA leaflet
- Yalcogrin SF 2002, State Forests
via reputable source 2003
- Yadboro SF 2002 State Forests via ChipStop 2003
- Yarindury SF 2002, State Forests
via reputable source 2003
4. pre-emptive logging of new national park
- Gibraltar Range National Park, 1998, Clarence
- Nymboi-Binderay NP, 1998, CEC
- Bulahdelah NP, 1998, CEC
Reference - logging of declared national park 1998 per Michael Moriarty of Clarence Environment Centre
in 'Carr fails to protect forests' northern forest flyer March 1999. To clarify Carr made the declaration of 3 new national
parks but authorised loggers to continue until the end of the year. Anyone who has seen a D9 bulldozer and chainsaw gang in
operation (perhaps under lights?) knows what a farcical loophole this creates for the loggers. Community protest prevented
4A. Pre-emptive logging of moratorium forest areas. Refer 'Logging ban loophole/Protected forests still being
felled' p16, 16/11/96 Daily Telegraph, Simon Benson
'Logging is continuing in at least 45 protected forest compartments
more than two months after the State Government banned it .....'
5. In addition important natural areas were destroyed
or released for ongoing destruction:
- rampant unfettered land clearing
* 19/3/2001 SMH page 3, plant scientist John Benson resigns in disgust from Carr's Native Vegetation
* Daily Telegraph's Simon Benson - 'Illegal land clearing is out of control' p8 29/3/01 states '
More than 30,000 hectares of native forest and bushland is being illegally cleared every year across NSW with the Government's
knowledge, according to secret documents obtained by The Daily Telegraph.
18/9/00 Daily Telegraph p24 'Land-clearing
rates at twice official level' and p19 8/8/01 reports 42,000 ha approved in the first six months of 2001, 77,000 approved
for 2000 (no count of illegal clearing)
* Also see http://sydney.foe.org.au/forests/nswclearing.html dated 13/3/2001
sourcing material from the ALP govt itself of 21 July 1999.
* Also see 'Plundered forests at mercy of farmers' James
WoodfordSydney Morning Herald 23/1/01 'Farmers are using legal loopholes to destroy the equivalent of at least 2,200 football
fields worth of woodlands each year...', '9 million trees need to be planted in the Murray-Darling Basin ...'
- Stockton Bight sand dunes with 8 year mining lease, 2001, activist leaflet/TWS Newcastle
Plateau and forest (see in point 4 above)
- Tomago koala habitat
- Lake Cowal for a a gold mine using cyanide
- ADI (Lend Lease owned) site at St Mary's, Western Sydney - 1,500 ha site
- Kosciuzko National Park - threat
of ski resort development in 8,000 ha of wilderness Sydney Morning Herald article (date) by Noel Plumb
The notorious Transgrid affair - state owned electricity authority illegally clears a swathe through Namadgi, Brindabella,
Kosciuzko National Parks causing outrage in the ACT and NSW governments (Canberra Times p1 29/5/01, SMH p1). Huge questions
arise as to how government ministers and departmental advisers were so ignorant of their portfolio responsibilities that this
occurred over at least 35 km. This reality makes the condemnations of the clearing by Premier Carr quite strange - it was
done by his government instrumentality for which he is unltimately responsible.
6. Generic observations for
north east nsw
A. according to Dailan Pugh of NEFA, March 1999:
"For the 240 forest ecosystems
39% of the targets are achieved. There are 38% of forest ecosystems under 50% of their targets, with 14% under 10% of their
targets. Some 359, 400 ha of forest ecosystems on public lands still require reservation to meet national reserve criteria."
in 'Carr fails to protect forests' northern forest flyer March 1999.
"For the 444 rare and threatened plant
species 22% of the targets are achieved. There 59% of plants under 50% of their targets and 29% under 10% of their targets."
in 'Carr fails to protect forests' northern forest flyer March 1999.
B. NEFA media release 22/3/02
"According to the Government's own data 5,500 hectares of oldgrowth forests have been logged in the north-east
since March 1999. ... The outcomes are equally grim for ecosystems in the region with more than 40,000 hectares of poorly
reserved forest ecosystems having been logged in the 3 year time period. This includes some 2,500 hectares of rare, endangered
and vulnerable ecosystems".
C. Wilderness & the North East by Keith Muir Director
Colong Foundation 18 Nov 1998
in six hectares of wilderness considered by process was protected The current round of north-east forest decisions affected
237,773 ha of wilderness outside reserves existing prior to the decision of last week.
Of this area only 37,226 ha
is to be reserved in the national park estate (and about one third of this area is impossible to reserve as wilderness because
some of the areas are now too small). The remainder, equalling 200,000 ha, is available for logging. In other words for every
one hectare protected in reserves, FIVE hectares were given to the loggers.'
'There is one million hectares
of wilderness in the north-east of NSW (1,002,310 ha), based on NPWS data provided to us yesterday. The Provisionally Identified
Wilderness figure(PIW) should be added to the NPWS identified wilderness figure. The PIW become identified wilderness under
the Wilderness Act, except for political intervention through the Forest legislation.
In other words: 803,438 ha (NPWS
id wilderness) + 198,872 ha (NPWS PIW)
TOTAL 1,002,310 ha
The PIW areas were to be identified under
the Wilderness Act after the CRA. Now less than half of the PIW areas will be identified as only the areas also to be reserved
in the national parks estate can be identified.'
7. Generic observations for SE NSW forests
A. 'The Eden Decision achieved 39% of required koala habitat in reserves. Because information on koala habitat requirements
is still rudimentary this can only serve as a rough guide to the outcome for koalas.' per Chris Allen South East Forest Conservation
Council, 13th December 1998.
B. 'Daishowa's Corporate Affairs Manager, Vince Phillips told the Senate Committee inquiring into the Regional Forest
Agreement Bill on 1 February that "about 80" log trucks go into the chipmill every day. ...Now the Environmental Impact Statement
for the proposed Eden Arms Depot (released a couple of weeks ago) reveals an average of 130 trucks a day travel along Edrom
Rd, with nowhere else to go but to the chipmill, per Harriett Swift, ChipStop 18 Nov 1999
8. General policy approach of the Carr Govt supporting entrenched native forest logging industry -
Bob Carr made these hopeful but ultimately misleading comments on January 27th 1996 in the Daily Telegraph page 37
(9 months after election March 25th 1995)
"We're now moving into a period of consolidation. To a large extent the first
year has been setting the agenda - now there is a lot of effort to come in the implementation.
"Take forestry. We
allocated a lot of money so we don't lose our high conservation value forests but it is now a matter of setting up alternative
"We must establish hardwood plantations, mobilise investment to set up plywood factories to add value
to the products they have been exporting in raw form, retraining workers from clapped-out timber mills to move with their
families to these better quality, safer and better paid jobs."
Suffice to say there is no plantation transition strategies out of native forests
from the Carr Govt in the last 5 years.
B. Admission by logging minister Yeadon in 2002, when he engaged the
author in conversation 2/5/02 1.30 pm outside Governor Macquarie Tower Sydney in words following or similar.
Tom McLoughlin - 'The Premier broke his promise on behalf of the government "to save
the forests" on election night in 1995'.
Minister Yeadon - "We never promised to protect all the forests."
- "Carr promised to end woodchipping by 2000.
Minister Yeadon - "It's true he did promise that but I never did, and
I NEVER WOULD."
(The Daily Telegraph ran a story that woodchipper Harris Daishowa had closed
but regretably it was the result of an April Fools joke media release on 1/4/090.)
C. Extract of media release
National Forest Summit (NFS) of environment groups December 2001:
"The NFS recognises and supports the role of non-violent direct action throughout Australia
in protecting native forests. The NFS calls on the Carr government to immediately halt logging of Badja and Shea's Nob State
Forests and to begin negotiations to protect high conservation value forests throughout NSW. The NFS will write a joint letter
to Premier Carr calling on the NSW government to desist from its inappropriate approach in dealing with Forest Rescues, particularly
in Badja and Shea's Nob State Forests."
D. Daily Telegraph 20/3/02 at page 23
"The 2001 State of the Environment Report claimed conditions had deteriorated since a
similar report to the Federal Government warned of the need for action five years ago.
NSW was singled out for continuing
land clearing rates which had accelerated."
E. Media releases on Carr's legal framework for entrenched logging late 1998
CARR WILL GO DOWN IN HISTORY,
Media Release and one page Analysis,
"What is even more galling is that the already compromised State Position,
developed jointly between State Forests, NPWS and the Resource and Conservation Assessment division of DUAP under ministerial
guidance, was further and significantly compromised following a Government meeting on Tuesday. It was at that meeting that
the decision to open up wilderness and more oldgrowth for logging was made.
"Today, Carr has truly earned his place
in history. Not for what he did for the forests but for how badly he did them over."
Mr. Pugh said. North East Forest Alliance, 12/11/98,
Carr's New Forestry Law, Old Growth and Wilderness Forests Sacrificed Rural Communities Threatened "The Premier's decision
to protect less than one third of the forests scientifically identified as needed for new national parks means that some 300,000
ha of old growth forests and up to 100,000 ha of wilderness in north east and south east NSW remain ou ide the reserve system."
...."State Forests is placed above the environmental planning controls under the Environmental Planning and Assessment Act
which apply to every other State agency or private developer, miner or logger in NSW. "
Noel Plumb 19 Nov. 1998 NATIONAL PARKS ASSOCIATION OF NSW INC
17 November 1998
'New forest law most regressive environmental legislation in 20 years'
'Conservationists today released legal advice which reveals that if the Government's
Forestry and National Parks Estate Bill 1998 is passed unamended it would be the most regressive environmental legislation
in twenty years....
'The advice from the Environmental Defenders Office (attached) notes that "this is the first environmental
legislation in 20 years to specifically remove open standing provisions. The advice summarises that the Bill significantly
erodes the protection of forests environments for the next 20 years by:
- exempting forestry operations from normal
environmental impact assessment procedures
- removing public participation rights and promoting secrecy in agreements,
- removing the public's rights to enforce the law and prevent breaches of environmental laws.
also notes that the Bill removes the ability to protect wilderness values under the Premier's own Wilderness Act.
Connor, Nature Conservation Council of NSW, Jeff Angel, Total Environment Centre, Noel Plumb, National Parks Association
PRO-WOODCHIP ACT MEANS ELECTORAL MAYHEM FOR ALP AND CONFLICT FOR 20 YRS,
Media Release, Friends of the Earth, 26/11/98
"The irony is that Boral's timber division - the driving force behind this draconian
legislation - is on the skids with return to shareholders for the Boral group as a whole crashing since 1988. By comparison
plantation based CSR has recently posted a 125% turn around in its timber division. 'This is not surprising.' 'Sadly, 3 million
tonnes of plantation sawlogs worth $100 million in royalties to the taxpayer remain unharvested in NSW which has 26% of Australia's
extensive plantation estate,' concluded Mr McLoughlin."
LOGGING IN NEW NATIONAL PARKS: CARR'S FOREST PLAN FAILS FIRST HURDLE, Media Release, The Wilderness Society, 16/12/98 "Logging
operations are still occurring in compartment 167 & 168 of the Bulahdelah State Forest, which surround "The Grandis" (until
recently, NSW tallest tree). This sets a disastrous precedent for NSW national parks and highlights the lack of respect S
tate Forests exhibits for high conservation forest areas, and indeed for the term 'national park'. "This is a smash &
grab operation by State Forests in the states new national parks, rather than cleaning-up and getting-out of these areas State
Forests are taking all they can get and leaving the mess for national parks to deal with", Said Mr Steve Rya n, Forest spokesperson
for The Wilderness Society."
CONSERVATIONISTS DUMP FAILED FOREST MANAGEMENT COMMITTEE, Media Release,
Nature Conservation Council, 17/12/98 "Mr Wright said that, Ms Lyn Orrego and Ms Pauline Nolan, the representatives
nominated by the Nature Conservation Council to the Technical Working Group on Ecologically Sustainable Forest Management,
would resign today. He said that the NCC would not se eking to further participate in the technical working group supervised
by the Resource and Conservation Division of the Department of Urban Affairs and Planning. "Without a forest reserve system
that meets the nationally agreed reserve criteria and which guarantees the survival of the hundreds of species of threatened
forest dependent plants and animals, no NSW forestry operations and no timber from NSW state for ests, can come close to being
ecologically sustainable," he said."
FOREST OUTCOMES CONDEMNED, Media Release, Nature Conservation
Council, 18/12/98 'Outcomes from the forest assessment process for the Eden and North East NSW regions, have been condemned
for breaching most of the key components of NSW Labor Party's Forestry Policy and contravening the National Forest Policy,
in a unanimous resolution carried at a special Summit meeting of NSW forest conservation groups, held in Sydney this week.
"The Premier has effectively ignored the results of the scientific assessments of forest values and in so doing has failed
to acknowledge the significant public interest in, and community expectations for, scientifically credible conservation outcomes,"
Mr Connor said that the NSW forest conservation groups present at the Forest Summit believed that the Premier
had betrayed their goodwill and co-operation and had co-opted their good names for use in NSW government propaganda via radio,
print and televis ion advertising."
9. There are lists and maps of intended logging zones in literally hundreds of state
forests in NSW over the last 7 years but we are still gathering these together and intend to check they did in fact get logged.
10. The file record over the last 3 years shows a tenacious public interest fight against Carr ministers and
Carr himself to prevent burning of native forests for power and/or charcoal production. This was a great victory for the NSW
environment movement the given following reports -
A. The Sydney Morning Herald reported the same
in 'New fuel for power stations: native forests' 26th Nov 1999 By JAMES WOODFORD, Environment Writer Sydney Morning Herald
'The NSW Treasurer has opened the way for the harvesting of State forests to provide fuel for power stations amid
warnings from environmentalists that this would be a return to ''prehistoric energy''.
Under one proposal by the electricity
industry, about 1.5 million tonnes of State forest trees would used as fuel, about twice the amount taken for timber and woodchipping.
Mr Egan has warned that the commercial survival of State Forests - manager of all publicly owned native forests in
NSW - may depend on such a radical decision, which could involve timber collected from all regions.'
B. the text of a media statement from the NSW Forest Summit: "Burning NSW Forests - beyond
belief 14 August 2000" which refers to a threat of "2 million tonnes of so called waste to be produced from forestry operations"
per year at risk from power furnaces and charcoal production.
11. The summer edition of the umbrella service group
Nature Conservation Council in NSW has the following damning front page story on the Carr performance on the general environment
prior to the promises of the current election campaign:
'Selling out the environment'
Kathy Ridge (pictured, lead story,
page 1 Environment NSW, the quarterly newsletter of the Nature Conservation Council of NSW Summer 2002/3
At the time
when the landscape of NSW and its dependent regional communities are suffering the worst drought in 100 years, the Carr government
has backed away from the very reforms that would have delivered a more robust environment.
The last two months has
[sic] seen the NSW government fail to put in place twoof the most important strategic natural resource management frameworks
- the Native Vegetation Management Strategy, and the State Water Management Outcomes Plan.
Both policy frameworks
were designed to guide the work of regional natural resource committees, including Catchment Management Boards, Regional Native
Vegetation Committees and the Water Management Committees.
Without clear policy positions being articulated by the
government, community based planning has been an utter failure dogged by poor data, insufficient resources and lack of transparency
and accountability in committee processes.
it has also limited the discussion of the value of the outcomes within
government. Each of the draft regional vegetation plans are of varying quality with no cohesive statewide direction being
discernible. The extensive, not to mention expensive, Water Sharing Plan process is going to deliver less than a 0.5 per cent
increase in water for the environment statewide, and very little of that increase is protected as environmental health water.
Agains the backdrop of landscape scale failure to address land clearing and over extraction from our rivers, the ongoing
destruction of old growth forests, woodchipping and charcoal threats, loss of valuable public lands to developers and suffocating
stacks in our suburbs, Carr could well be advised to not rest on his environmental record. .....
It will be a long
'hot' summer, both politically and environmentally speaking.'
12. REPORT FINDS LOGGING UNSUSTAINABLE media release by North East Forest Alliance (undated)
"The NSW Auditor-General's report tabled in State parliament yesterday finds that current timber commitments
from public forests are unsustainable and that there are serious doubts that State Forests NSW can meet its 20 year Timber
Supply Agreements" said Susie Russell, spokesperson for the North East Forest Alliance
"The Audit Office clearly
states that it does not consider the timber supply strategy outlined in the north-east Forest Agreements constitutes sustained
yield. It notes that 'contracted supply volumes were set by the NSW Government.... before sustainable wood flow yields were
determined' and 'The total volume of timber to be supplied in terms of the agreements is in excess of what [State Forests]
predicts could be sustained over a 100 year period.' "
"It is evident that the NSW Government will never be
able to claim it is managing its public forests on a sustainable basis until such time as they dramatically cut timber commitments
to a more realistic level." Ms Russell said.
"We have a biodiversity crisis that is going to be exacerbated
by an industry and a government agency desperate to get every last tree to meet impossible supply commitments in a manner
that is neither environmentally nor economically sustainable".
"However, NEFA is concerned that the Auditor
General has only undertaken a superficial review of State Forests' actual timber assessments. The report accepts State Forests'
exaggerated claims at face value, without any in depth review. It is also apparent that
in some of the information
supplied to the Audit Office, the Auditor General was mislead by State Forests NSW.
"We are particularly disappointed
at the Auditor General's failure to consider any of the numerous concerns revealed in NEFA's 200 page critique of State Forests'
timber assessment. We had expected that there would be a detailed review of all the issues we had identified but they have
"Given that the NSW Government has intervened to stop the inquiry that the Resource and Conservation
Assessment Council had agreed was required. This now means that there will now be no independent in depth review of State
Forests grossly inflated resource assessments.
"We will be going back to the Audit Office and asking them
again to undertake an in-depth review of State Forests' timber assessment methodology and outcomes. It is apparent that if
they don't do it then it will never be done." Ms. Russell said.
For more information contact Susie Russell
NEFA C/ Susie Russell, P.O. Elands,NSW 2429,Australia, +61 0265 504481,
13. Status report of forest protection from The Wilderness Society's Andrew Wong as at
SOUTH COAST FORESTS: REVISED LIST OF ICON AREAS UNDER THREAT, 21/11/99
National Parks and Wildlife Service (NPWS) and State Forests have developed a joint agency / NSW government set of options
for the South Coast RFA. This consists of three options - to supply industry with 55,000 cubic metres, 45,000 and 35,000 respectively.
All three options do not achieve significant areas the conservation movement has identified for protection, and assume old-growth
forest outside the reserve system will be logged. A final decision is likely to made on wood supply and reservations based
on: the three options; the Commonwealthâ??s opinions; and politics and negotiations etc. that occur from now on.
is a description of areas left out of the 35,000 option (and therefore all options proposed by the NSW government) and the
45,000 option. The 55,000 option is not listed, as it would be a disaster for just about everywhere.
OF 35 K OPTION (AND THEREFORE ALL OPTIONS):
* The bulk of Badja State Forest. This includes all of Badja above the
steepest section of the eastern escarpment and south of Woila Creek Road. This area includes the long-standing icon and biodiversity
Ċ?hot spotâ?? of Balook Road (compartments 28, 29, 31 and 46). This area has had a large number of blockades against logging
between 1992 and 1994, including a two week blockade. The area contains at least ten threatened species, including the Squirrel
Glider and Golden-tipped Bat (two extremely rare species). It also contains extensive areas of gigantic wet old-growth forest
with sweeping tree-fern understoreys.
* Large sections of Dampier State Forest. This includes Gulph Creek and Bumbo
Creek catchments, the eastern half of Big Belimba Creek catchment, and a link south to Wandella / Deua National Park. Gulph
and Bumbo Creeks contain the most extensive rainforests in the South Coast. Big Belimba Creek is a wet old-growth forest valley.
* Wandella - Peak Alone. An area almost completely surrounding Peak Alone, bordering private lands around the edge
of Wandella State Forest, has been left out. This includes most of the slopes of the magnificent Peak Alone mountain. This
area has very important catchment values, as well as high old-growth and threatened species values.
* Conjola link.
The link through Yerriyong, Jerrawangala and McDonald State Forests from Conjola to Morton National Park has been greatly
* Kianga. An area of Bodalla State Forest near Narooma has been completely ignored. It is a coastal forest
(within one km of the coast).
* Bimberamala. Most of the upper catchment of the Bimberamala River (the major tributary
of the Clyde River) has been ignored. This area is extremely important for protection of the Clydeâ??s unique pristine nature,
as well as for extensive rainforests and as a corridor under the Kings (Canberra - Batemans Bay) Highway (Cabbage Tree Creek
is the only chance for gaining an underpass under the highway, essential for wildlife movement).
* Flat Rock. Approximately
the western half of Flat Rock, adjoining Pigeon House Mountain in Morton National Park, has been left out.
Phone (02) 6249 6491