Memories of coffee and chocolate ...
We read recently former federal treasurer wax lyrical in the Sydney Morning Herald recently how the insulation 'debacle' has involved more fatalities than nuclear energy has over the same time frame. or something like that.
But how would Costello know, (long term lap puppy of former PM Howard pictured above).
We posted this very real threat to humanity in a western country, here on a crikey comment string late last week:
“Infant Deaths And Childhood Cancer Drop Dramatically After Nuclear Plants Close
November 30, 2001, New York, NY”
“Dramatic declines in local infant death and childhood cancer rates occurred soon after the closing of eight nuclear power plants, according to a new report announced by New York State Assemblyman Richard Brodsky, Radiation and Public Health Project, and the STAR Foundation. The study documents a 17.4% reduction in infant mortality in the downwind counties within 40 miles two years after reactor closing, compared to a national decline of just 6.4%. Large declines occurred in all eight areas near closed reactors, and remained above national trends for at least six years after closing. The information appears as an article published in the March/April 2002 edition of Archives of Environmental Health.
“We finally have reliable peer-reviewed accurate data attaching the nuclear power plants to death and injury in the host communities, this is a sobering and significant scientific study and we all need to take it seriously,” stated New York State Assemblyman Richard Brodsky. “It is critical that more studies of this type be performed, so that we fully understand the risks posed by nuclear reactors,” added Westchester County legislator Thomas Abinanti.
“Nuclear power is a failed experiment that is expensive and dangerous,” said Scott Cullen, Executive Director of STAR. “This study confirms the best of public health principles: that when you remove a known cause of illness, health improves,” said Cullen. “What is gratifying about the research is that it showed childhood health measures increasing so dramatically and quickly after the reactors closed and provides good news that we can strive towards.”
In three of the eight areas with available data, cancer diagnosed in children less than five years of age declined 25.0% in the seven years after reactor closing, compared to a 0.3% increase nationally. Children exposed to radiation are of increased risk for cancer, says Joseph Mangano, MPH MBA, the principal author of the study who is affiliated with the New York research group Radiation and Public Health Project.
This study is most relevant to New York City because over 8% of the nation’s population lives within 50 miles of the Indian Point reactor. Counties downwind and within 40 miles of Indian Point include the Bronx, Dutchess, Manhattan, Nassau, Putnam, Queens, and Westchester in New York, and Fairfield County in Connecticut. Over 8.5 million persons live in these counties, where 110,000 babies are born each year. “
with link to http://www.radiation.org/spotlight/closed.html
Pictures: Lifted off Fairfax press 4 March 2010, Sydney Morning Herald and Brisbane Times respectively.
Author’s general introductory note
This is not a well packaged story. It’s a contemporaneous traverse of the Sunday television free to air political talkies indicating the agenda of Establishment interests: Better to know ones rivals and allies in Big Politics and Big Media. Perhaps the greatest utility is the headline synthesis above of the 3 or 4 shows followed in this session.
For actual transcripts and/or video feeds go to the programme web sites quoted including Riley Diary on 7. And note transcripts don’t really give you the image content value.
Other sources of pollie talkies on Sunday include SkyNews paytv Sunday Agenda, Radio National Monica Attard Sunday Profile show. And of course Sunday night shows SBS Dateline, Sixty Minutes and now Sunday Tonight on 7.
- Our image last Sunday of Rudd in doctors gown seems to have scooped the big media by 48 hours. It was a cliché that was always going to happen, and sure enough it did on front page of the Sydney Telegraph and tv pictures. But the green light was obvious first with Ruddster body language leaning into the camera during the interview on Insiders which is why we ran with the image ahead of the rest. Exhibit 1: Tragic life watching wonky political media.
- Keating’s Lend Lease sponsored giant phallus over land at Barangaroo reminds of Keating as overdevelopment consultant to Westfield at Bondi – regional sized facility in sub regional centre sucking life out of family retail elsewhere. This was around 1997 and we were councilor at Waverley in Bondi Beach ward. Keating consultancy was covert, revealed some years later. In 1996-7 a similar Mac Bank – Lend Lease private proposal for heavy rail station in the park at the Beach – raising the prospect of … you guessed it high rise over Lend Lease air space rights … on the water. The locals rejected this potential monster out of hand. In conclusion as we always say with Keating – self interest is always trying – just like his declared consultancy for power privatization with Wylie Lazzard investment bank. So was Keating now or then a covert paid consultant for Lend Lease in 1997 over the Bondi Rail private development proposal.
- Opinion section of SMH on web is now “National Times” so can’t get a line on leading article so easily anymore. Also to compete with Crikey?
- Front of SD Telegraph off their web front page again can’t easily guage their press front page blowtorch. Maybe international web access until we get to the local library like this http://www.pressdisplay.com/pressdisplay/viewer.aspx
- This week SAM noted Frank Ernest Sartor NSW Env Minister talking frogs, to learn the SD Telegraph has a frog logo on their environment blogger rip of SAM here which also uses a frog for years now? Go the Frogs.
- Marginals in Sydney in play over redgums and other forest like Marrickville, Balmain, Strathfield, Coogee and no doubt more. In this sense big Saturday telegraph story about redgum sawmillers is right about politics but they ignore the science which is all for conservation via Govt Resource Audit Council.
- PM Rudd getting aggressive in echo of rival Abbott over health, or is it his father’s death coming back in his dreams?
- Peter Costello hopelessly wrong about safety of nuclear power in his Fairfax opinion piece in cheap shot at insulation fatalities by comparision. Notice this quote and links from a US public interest study on closure of 8 reactors, as posted by SAM on Crikey comment string late last week:
“Infant Deaths And Childhood Cancer Drop Dramatically After Nuclear Plants Close
November 30, 2001, New York, NY”
“Dramatic declines in local infant death and childhood cancer rates occurred soon after the closing of eight nuclear power plants, according to a new report announced by New York State Assemblyman Richard Brodsky, Radiation and Public Health Project, and the STAR Foundation. The study documents a 17.4% reduction in infant mortality in the downwind counties within 40 miles two years after reactor closing, compared to a national decline of just 6.4%. Large declines occurred in all eight areas near closed reactors, and remained above national trends for at least six years after closing. The information appears as an article published in the March/April 2002 edition of Archives of Environmental Health.”
With full quotes at
with link to http://www.radiation.org/spotlight/closed.html
- We helped with a charity case in the Supreme Court NSW Equity Division which is still to have a costs hearing. Now we read in this weekend SMH that Justice David Lloyd who found the state govt involved in “land bribes” has retired from the Land and Environment Court – which is big news in itself. We had another charity case smashed by Justice Lloyd on the basis the client was a bankrupt – at the hands of corrupt sandminer and council mates.
Now Lloyd the respected Beak is being blocked it is implied in SMH by politicians in the state Govt to work on in the Supreme Court Equity Division. Interesting because we wrote up case #1 mentioned above (we are named in the title as next friend for the client with mental illness) in the Equity Division and sent it to the media officers for the Supreme Court for the information of the chief judge. As evidence of where the legal system has worked to protect the most vulnerable.
A natural fit for Justice Lloyd surely. The NSW govt could be heading to ICAC over this one a la Tim Moore/Greiner Affair (Moore is a Commissioner at same L&E Court today) if ICAC were not so disempowered. Former chief of ICAC was Justice Cripps – who we understand in private practice made face to face deals with Sam Haddad around 2000 for a sandminer client, when previously Cripps was Chief Judge of the L&E Court 1985-1992, and then appointed boss of ICAC 2004-2009. Wheels within wheels eh in the State of ALP.
The ICAC website doesn’t seem to show Cripps biography anymore. But we grabbed it in a previous SAM post, and notice he is working with another Govt appointment the Sentencing Commission or something. Lloyd must be pondering such favour ….
THE HON JERROLD CRIPPS QC2004-present - Commissioner, Independent
10 Meet the Press: 8- 8-30 am
Intro film wrap curriculum, health reform. Dep PM Gillard is guest.
Bonge in the chair.
JG crocodile tears for Belinda Neal lost pre-selection. [Metaphor for crony ALP loss in next NSW state election?] Gillard State Govt’s will go broke paying for health. Q. Politics of referenda, senate vexed. Grab of Abbott compare with insulation competence.
Humour out take more revealing for pollies using children again. Big Media are starting to notice the exploitation.Panel is chubbies Glenn Milne News Corp, Fran Kelly. Grab of Chris Pyne host of policies not implemented. Tough questions on implementation from Milne, answered quite well with confidence and strong detail but th Humour out take cartoon of giant pill or sopository. Adbreak is work choices reprise “the phrase work choices is dead” credibility attack advert. Tim Baxter health bureaucrat for Kennett and Carr. Implementation is the key. Agrees with Dep PM serious adjustments for costs in state bureaucracy. GST increase?
Riley Diary 7, from 8.40amWork safe tear jerker advert PR sponsored by NSW Govt. Manipulative politicking?PM focus apology with John Cleese show. Policy wonk. Abbott referred to as Slugger. Q& A at end Riley says Rudd is back on the policy front.
9 Sunday newshour Laurie Oakes interview 8.44 am
Minister Roxon in black style clothes, too formal methinks. Perhaps for gravitas. Preselection on Neal. Anzac Day. Missed a fair bit of it.
Insiders 2: 9- 10am
Uhlmann in the chair. Pop package PM Rudd focus. Laura Tingle AFR (smart), Brian Toohey, Phil Coorey – all Fairfax.
Dwell on Belinda Neal replacement. Deborah O’Neil has the goods by sound of her.
Joe Hockey as shadow treasurer and guest. Blah blah. Vox pop as usual. Panel on PM apology and education. Toohey says Rudd is a bad policy maker who thinks he’s good.
Inside Business with Alan Kohler .
If there is no evidence of a sinister crime, could a 3 year old child walk such a long way and die of dehydration? Trying to find where the planes fly? Or even be abducted and released get lost and similarly die of heat and dehydration?
From our uni science classes we always recall the surface area volume ratio of living things. Smaller volume (as for a small child) means relatively bigger surface area to lose heat and perspire. Some UN and other web pages discuss dehydration mainly in respect of global problems of Acute diarrhoeal diseases:
The symptoms become increasingly severe with greater water loss. One's heart and respiration rates will increase to compensate for decreased plasma volume and blood pressure, while body temperature may rise because of decreased sweating. Around 5% to 6% water loss, one may become groggy or sleepy, experience headaches or nausea, and may feel tingling in one's limbs ( paresthesia). With 10% to 15% fluid loss, muscles may become spastic, skin may shrivel and wrinkle, vision may dim, urination will be greatly reduced and may become painful, and delirium may begin. Losses of greater than 15% are usually fatal. http://rehydrate.org/dehydration/index.html
We actually walked from Melbourne Airport in January 2010 all the way to the first tram stop which must be about 5 km. It was hot dry flat country. We did find a tap along the way. We had bad shoes we threw away the next day.
Our purpose was to learn more about the layout of Mebourne complete with compass. We walked to and from Kingsford Smith airport in Sydney same trip partly to avoid the outrageous premium on the train ticket.
We've done similar at Avalon to train line at Lara in Victoria in 2006 or so. A bit eccentric but it's also quite interesting.
Picture: Spot the non carnivore? It's a trick question from this zoology grad pseudo lawyer. They are all carnivorous, not least 'talking turkey' Minister Frank Ernest Sartor top middle. But give him time and he might yet surprise in the environment portfolio ...
'The ecological equivalent of a Tasmanian Tiger. Sounds like a motor bike. '
Oh gawd. Which is the biggest clue this is a PR choreography, with timing at the control of the government, perhaps even to offset the growing furore over forest destruction reported here on SAM recently? (Redgums and koalas in southern NSW):
'Extinct' yellow frog reappears in NSW 4 Mar 2010
and so on.
Child death is a terrible thing.
Here is this story leading the web press today:
SHANNON TONKIN Luke Selwyn, 6, fails to return after going for a walk with his family's two dogs as police find his body in a dam.
Last month The Sydney Morning Herald alerted urban readers to this debacle of land use policy in the 21st Century:
Logging plan poses threat to precious koala colony
BEN CUBBY January 25, 2010
LOGGING is set to start within weeks in a forest that supports the last known koala colony on the NSW far south coast.
The NSW Government is yet to release data from a comprehensive survey of koala habitat and population in Mumbulla and Murrah state forests, near Tathra, even though some trees have been marked for removal.
The two-year koala survey, which could be published this week, is believed to contain strong evidence of koala occupation in several parts of the eucalypt forest.
Sources painted a picture of fractious debate between staff from the Department of Environment and Climate Change, which managed the koala research effort, and Forests NSW, the government agency that will manage the logging operation.
One source described a map of the area that had been drawn and redrawn in search of a compromise between felling trees and maintaining enough forest to allow the koalas to survive.
The NSW Greens and south coast environment groups are campaigning for a moratorium on logging in the koala habitat.
"The koala population on the NSW south-east coast is at a critical level,'' the Greens MP Lee Rhiannon said.
"Yet the NSW Government is prioritising the interests of the logging industry over the ongoing survival of this much-loved native animal.''
The logging operation, due to begin in early March, would involve taking some high-quality timber and some timber for woodchips.
Most of the timber from felled trees in the region goes to a mill in Eden, which exports woodchips to Japan.
As well as the remaining koala population, which has been identified by sightings, droppings and scratch marks on trees, the forest is known to provide a home for endangered long-nosed potoroos.
The Environment Department is ''committed to the protection of koalas and their habitat'', a spokesman said.
The department had engaged in ''what is arguably the most extensive koala survey of its type ever undertaken in Australia, in parts of the Mumbulla and Murrah state forests which are believed to contain koala habitat''.
''The survey results will be used in current negotiations with Forests NSW to ensure the longer-term protection of critical koala habitat identified in the survey,'' he said.
The marsupials are listed as a vulnerable species in NSW, but there is controversy over how many are still alive in the wild.
The Australian Koala Foundation has said its research shows there were only 43,000 to 80,000 left on the Australian mainland, based on data from more than 1000 forests surveys.
The group is heading a new push to get the species listed as ''endangered'' via the threatened species committee.
But many other researchers think the foundation's koala population figure is a serious underestimate, and say that in some areas koala populations are not in decline.
At the time we noted here on SAM that a former SMH environment reporter James Woodford who now doubles as a "real dirt ....environmental news" blogger on the NSW south coast ("the real dirt, the whole dirt, nothing but the dirt"), author and opinion writer on SMH still, was seemingly ignorant of the koala furore in his tree change domestic bliss. We hope it was ignorance but we believe otherwise. We detect a history of airbrushing NSW Govt "dirt" being the source of many if not all of his stories as a journalist on the drip.
Since then the green movement on the NSW south coast has been in uproar for a solid 6 weeks over this vandalism of icon species habitat, as per media releases and articles below. Indeed what would the United States side of the Premier Keneally family think of such wanton killing of koalas creating a regional extinction in a section of NSW?
We have now received this notice of a public meeting featuring Deborah Tabbart, a high profile koala campaigner from the Australian Koala Foundation:
Logging threats to the South Coast at Murrah, Mumbulla and Tanja
Guest speaker: Deborah Tabbart, Australian Koala Foundation
7pm Tathra Town Hall
Monday 8th March 2010
Related community and/big media follow, all apparently invisible to dirty blogger James Woodford even when it's his own backyard (but not here 6 hours drive away!):
Additional public meeting here nearby forest at Western Yurammie
[The Canberra Times]26 Jan, 2010 01:00 AMA colony of koalas in state forest near Tathra on the NSW South Coast could be wiped out by woodchip logging scheduled to begin within weeks, the ACT Conservation Council says.
Executive director John Hibberd has written to Federal environment minister Peter Garrett and NSW Premier Kristina Keneally urging them to intervene to save the Mumbulla State Forest koalas.
''This is the only known koala colony on the far South Coast, and represents the last remnant of the once extensive koala populations in the Bega Valley,'' Mr Hibberd said.
''Shooting, clearing, feral animals and fire have all decimated the koalas of the region. We cannot afford to risk these koalas now.''
The NSW Government launched a comprehensive survey of the area three years ago after local Aboriginal land council staff unexpectedly discovered two koalas in the Mumbulla forest.
The first stage of the survey, the largest of its kind undertaken in NSW, assessed 400 sites and more than 12000 trees.
Early results showed evidence of koalas at about 50 sites in forest between Gulaga and the Mumbulla mountains.
Based on these findings, the NSW Environment Department issued a statement which described Mumbulla as ''a stronghold of the species'' on the far South Coast.
The Government has not released the final results of the two-year survey, but the early findings were posted online as evidence of the survey's success.
The logging operations, due to begin in March, will harvest high quality timber as well as woodchips for export to Japan. Forests NSW is required under state conservation laws to leave a percentage of koala habitat trees in the area being logged.
Artist and former fashion designer Prue Acton said the threat to the South Coast koalas highlighted the need to stop a national decline in koala numbers by listing them as a nationally threatened species.
'' While the Commonwealth has not yet listed this animal as a threatened species, there is enough evidence around now about its decline that we simply cannot afford to take any further risks with its future,'' she said.
Mr Hibberd said the koalas needed sufficient space for their young to move into new territories, and any post-logging fires ''will spell the end for them''.
".....protect koalas and honour the regional forest agreement."
NSW Government must release all koala data: Constance17 Feb, 2010 10:22 AM
LIBERAL MP Andrew Constance has called for the release of all NSW Labor Government information pertaining to koalas on the state's Far South Coast.
"It is in everybody interests that all data is publicly available so that the wider community and the timber industry can see how the Department of Environment and Climate Change and Forests NSW are addressing any concerns relating to koalas," Mr Constance said.
"The advice I have is that there are a number of well established koala colonies in the region and it is in everybody's interests that the community and the industry have confidence in what the State Government is doing to protect koalas and honour the regional forest agreement.
"The government has to be open, accountable and transparent so that any debate undertaken in the community is done with all information available.
"Whilst claims that there is only one colony left, the government must outline what colonies exist in both the National Parks system and State Forests on the Far South Coast and what measures are being undertaken to protect such colonies from being decimated by wildfire.
Bob Brown in the 1990s claimed the national park in the Tantawanglo as the most important koala habitat in south east NSW with an estimated 40-45 adult koala population.
"If there is an issue with any koala colony on the Far South Coast then an explanation needs to be given by the Minister Steve Whan, who has had nothing to say thus far on this issue, on how any concerns will be addressed.”
Join the cause on Facebook
Save the Mumbulla and Five Forests Koalas from logging
........................................[19 Feb 2010, full copy PDF link on image]
..........................................................Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 9:57 PMSubject: [chipstop] koala report
Koala surveys in the coastal forests of the Bermagui–Mumbulla area: 2007–09 – interim report
"Figure 1 indicates that there have been few reports of koalas in other coastal and foothill forests of the Eden Region since 1996. This reduction in reporting rate suggests an overall decline in the regional population. "
WHAT HAPPENED TO THE BODALLA KOALAS THAT WERE IN THE TUROSS RIVER CATCHMENT? WERE THEY MADE LOCALLY EXTINCT DUE TO LOGGING IN THEIR HOME RANGE? COMPARTMENTS 3036 & 3037 HAD KOALA RECORDS IN 2005, HAVE THESE KOALAS PERSISTED?
ADVISE MAKE ALL FEED TREES LISTED AS PROTECTED THROUGHOUT THE EDEN AND SOUTHERN FOREST REGIONS
ADVISE THE PRECAUTIONARY PRINCIPLE OF ESFM BE THE IMMEDIATE ADAPTIVE MANAGEMENT POLICY ADOPTED BY THE GOVERNMENT
ADVISE LET NATIVE FOREST STAND.
GET YOUR KOALA MASKS READY!
[South East Forest Rescue]
Sent: Wednesday, February 24, 2010 10:27 AMSubject: another letter on koalas
Hi All,Sorry to keep sending these emails, but we are trying to get the attention of the state government on this urgent koala issue. A preliminary DECCW report released yesterday confirmed that there is a small healthy recovering population of about 50 koalas on the NSW south coast. ForestsNSW intends to log these forests irrespective of the findings, possibly as early as Monday. This will almost certainly spell the end for these koalas, which are nearly extinct on the south coast. It’s been shown that letters and phone calls, especially to your local members, are one of the most effective ways of getting politicians to respond – better than emails. On the other hand, since time is very short, a letter, email or phone call to one of the pollies below might be the best strategy. It would be great if you could adapt this letter in any way you want and send it. Many thanks, and no obligation,PS You might like to watch this fantastic Youtube video produced for Japanese viewers by Japanese-Australian campaigner, Anja Light.
The Hon Ian Macdonald, MLC,Minister for Mineral and Forest ResourcesGovernor Macquarie Tower
Level 36, 1 Farrer Place, SYDNEY NSW 2000ORPremier Kristina KeneallyMember for Heffron,Shop 117, 747 Botany Road, ROSEBERY NSW 2018Dear ,Your urgent action is needed to save the koalas of the far south coast. The preliminary DECCW report, released yesterday, confirmed a small healthy recovering population of about 50 koalas on the NSW south coast, in the Mumbulla forest.ForestsNSW intends to log this forest very soon, irrespective of the findings of this report, of any debate on the findings, or of the public release of the full report, including the koala habitat mapping. In addition, the compartments will be burnt after logging, which will further decimate the remaining koalas.Logging and burning could result in the extinction of south coast koalas, by destroying habitat and expansionary corridors, and by directly killing koalas in both surveyed and unsurveyed areas. Compartments in other as yet unsurveyed forests are also due to be logged and burnt in the near future, and these may also contain small populations of recovering koalas that have not yet been identified.Australia’s top koala experts recognise the far south coast as a region where our national icon is in serious trouble. Koalas have a range up to 50km, so leaving small ‘cells’ for koala habitats is not effective to safeguard populations. These koalas need space if their population is going to grow to a viable size, capable of withstanding disease, drought and fire. Koalas must find trees with nutrient rich leaves for their highly specialised diet, and males need to find new territory. The requirements of koalas are poorly understood, so it is impossible to ascertain what trees they will need, and in which direction they will need to move. These forests are also home to other endangered species, such as Long-Nosed Potoroos, Sooty Owls and Eastern Grey Headed Flying Foxes, as well as being critical habitat for the endangered Swift Parrot.
The NSW government appears to be placing very short sighted interests over the survival of this courageous animal, over our natural heritage and over the expansion of industries such as tourism on the south coast. The koala, one of our iconic native animals, could face destruction in these forests, for the sake of a very short term supply of woodchips and sawlogs, when there are now enough plantation resources on-line in Australia to ensure that no native forest needs to be logged.The NSW Labor government has a wonderful opportunity here to demonstrate its environmental credentials in the lead up to the next election. We don’t believe that this Labor government will want to leave the demise of the koala on the south coast as part of its legacy. You can save these animals and we are asking you to act now by putting an immediate halt to logging in the south east forests.
[ABC SE NSW radio]
Forests New South Wales has labelled an interim report into the state's South East koala colonies as "another hurdle" to its logging plans.
After two years of fieldwork the report was released this week, identifying a healthy koala population in areas including the Mumbulla State Forest, near Bermagui.
The department says it must begin logging in parts of the forest, because it is tied to a supply agreement with the timber industry.
Regional Manager Ian Barnes says there are many years left in the agreement.
"The government, in good faith, in exchange for the loss of resources by creating new national parks, gave an assurance to the industry that supply would be continued for 20 years," he said.
"So we've got at least 10 years to run on that agreement."
Mr Barnes says the report reveals more koala activity than expected in parts of the forest, which complicates arrangements under the Regional Forest Agreement signed in 1999.
[ABC radio SE NSW]
Conservationists say they will confront loggers head-on in an effort to save the habitat of a small colony of koalas on the far south coast of New South Wales.
Surveys by the Environment Department have found evidence of a recovering population of around 50 koalas in the Mumbulla state forest, south of Bermagui.
The New South Wales Government is due to start logging parts of the forest next month.
Most of the timber is to be sent to a mill in Eden, which exports some of it as woodchips to Japan.
John Hibberd from the ACT Conservation Council says if NSW Environment Minister Frank Sartor lets the logging go ahead, the koala population will be wiped out.
"I think it's absolutely staggering that we're still having this debate," he said.
"The south coast is marked by fantastic beaches, beautiful forests and yet we're prepared to log the forests and destroy an iconic species like koalas for the sake of supporting a foreign-owned industry that's heavily subsidised by the NSW taxpayer."
Mr Hibberd will meet with Mr Sartor in Sydney today together with other conservation groups.
A meeting between environmentalists and Mr Sartor yesterday failed to reach any agreement to protect the koalas.
Noel Plumb from conservation group Chip Busters says it is almost inevitable there will be direct conflict in the forests.
"The community is not going to allow this koala population to become extinct because you've got an arrogant state forest agency that won't listen to anybody," he said.
Meanwhile, deputy director-general of the Environment Department, Joe Woodward, says State Forests has agreed to hold off on some of its logging plans in the area.
"Importantly, [State] Forests have stated that they won't be going in and initially logging in those areas where the koalas have been identified," he said.
"Then we'll be having further discussions with State Forests to work out what can be done to protect the koalas."
SERCA South East Regional Conservation Alliance
Conservation Council ACT Region
MEDIA RELEASE - 27 February 2010
Koala Crisis Deepens in South East Forests
The crisis surrounding the possible extinction of koalas in the South East Forests deepened yesterday, as conservation groups met with the NSW Environment Minister, Frank Sartor.
“The Minister is deeply concerned at the situation but seems embattled on many fronts with forest issues,” said spokespersons for the South East Regional Conservation Alliance (SERCA).
“State Forests will not rule out the start of logging in the key koala areas as early as next Monday but are also effectively blocking negotiations (to protect the koalas) with the Department of Environment, Climate Change and Water (DECCW) and the National Parks and Wildlife Service (NPWS).”
“It was apparent to us in the discussions with the Minister and his senior officers yesterday that State Forests has refused to supply the critical, specific timber-supply figures that would enable Minister Sartor to negotiate for alternative supply arrangements with the Minister for Forests.”
“The Minister repeatedly expressed his concern that alternative supply arrangements had to be put in place because of contractual commitments to the logging industry".
Concerned environment groups say "Such figures are, according to their own logic, critical if the koalas are really to be protected from the intensive logging and wood-chipping operations now proposed by State Forests in the koala area.”
“State Forests has also broken its public commitment, made at a community meeting in Bermagui in 2007* that there would be genuine community consultation about the future of these forests once the NPWS koala survey was released by DECC.”
The completed Report was finally released by DECCW only on 23 February 2010 but without the maps critical for clear community information. The survey covers approximately 10,000 hectares of the Mumbullah and Murrah State Forests which lie between Bermagui and Bega.
“This survey does however confirm south coast conservationists and community groups statements of the past 10 years, that there is a small but potentially viable population of koalas barely hanging on in the south east forests.”
Noel Plumb, John Hibberd and Prue Acton "expressed the deep concern of their respective organisations to the Minister that, given State Forests' present attitude, there would inevitably be direct conflict in the these forests if State Forests attempted to start logging operations. Members of the south coast communities are sick to death of 40 years of woodchipping and associated environmental destruction, we are determined to save the Far South Coast koalas.”
For further comment;
John Hibberd, Conservation Council ACT Region, Mobile 0407292657;
Prue Acton O.B.E. SERCA Merimbula
ph. 0264945144, m. 0419393203.
MEDIA RELEASE 28 February 2010
Koalas Doomed in South East Forests
Sell Out In the Wind
Conservation groups today claimed that the NSW Department of Environment (DoE) was dooming the last remaining koala colony in the South East Forests by caving into the NSW logging agency, State Forests.
“DoE has effectively sold out on the survival of the last koalas in the South East Forests as it tries to negotiate with State Forests on a grossly unequal basis”, said spokespersons for the groups.
“We insist that conservation representatives be included in the negotiations to ensure the koalas get a fair go at survival.”
“DoE has failed to insist on the critical information on timber supply from State Forests so that it can actually negotiate on the basis of alternative supply sources. This information is vital to get around the claimed short term supply problem for a local timber mill.”
“ We know that the reality is that most of the timber, up to 90%, felled in this region goes straight to the Eden chipmill. State Forests has been caught time after time trying to claim a supply crisis for saw mills when none exists, or should exist if State Forests was competent.”
“DoE has tried to hide its desperate situation with the misleading statement that State Forests won’t be “initially logging in those areas where the koalas have been identified” but all this means is that State Forests intends to woodchip the forests all around the actual koala sightings.” **
“The end result will be the same – extinction of the last koala colony in the South East Forests from lack of sufficient forest habitat to feed and shelter them.”
For further comment, images;Prue Acton SERCA 6494 5144 (Merimbula).
Picture: File picture of this long running saga as per ex premier named in the banner.
Earlier this week the front page of The Australian led with a confronting/compassionate speech by federal Agriculture minister Tony Burke along the lines that it would have been alot kinder to implement transition out of drought declared farms 7 years ago. He mentioned self harm by farmers in recent years despite being on Exception Circumstances subsidy and even after the drought had broken because they had exhausted their capital, reached the ceiling of EC benefits, and have no great prospects by the next drought or capacity to loan for current investment. Leading to self harm. A hard story to be sure.Then we heard a 5 year 6,000 cubic metre per year deal for logging to continue until a national park is created in toto in the river red gums of NSW:
Yesterday the Sydney Morning Herald ran this protest story:
BRIAN ROBINS March 3, 2010
Chopping mad ... environmentalists protesting against the decision raised a banner outside the Premier's office. Photo: Nick Moir
The decision of the former premier Nathan Rees to immediately end logging of the Riverina redgums has been reversed by the state government.
It has opted for a five-year wind-down of logging, coupled with the establishment of national and regional parks that cover much of the contested area.
But getting the necessary legislation through Parliament is expected to be difficult, with the Coalition, Shooters and Greens parties all indicating opposition.
The state government said it would protect 107,000 hectares of Riverina redgums and set up an $80 million support package with logging to be wound down over the next five years.
Mr Rees proposed locking up the 42,000 hectares of the Millewa forest Riverina redgums in a national park, along with further unspecified areas along the Murray, Murrumbidgee and Lachlan rivers.
Environmental groups slammed the government for ''chopping the promised area in half''. The Greens want a total ban on logging while the Shooters are opposed to any halt to logging.
''This is clearly a deal with the Greens to win their preferences at next year's election,'' the Shooters MLC Robert Brown said of the government's proposal. ''We'll vote against it, as will the Nationals and Liberals, I suspect.''
The Greens MLC Ian Cohen said: ''Don't be surprised if I oppose it. It's a Labor-Nationals stitch-up. I am seriously unimpressed, and will be seeking advice. It's a pathetic compromise that leaves half of the magnificent Millewa Forest open for logging.''
The opposition also slammed the decision, saying that ''on face value, we'll be opposing'' the legislation because the government has ignored the local communities.
''The only reason that the redgums in the Barmah-Millewa area are in a reasonable condition is because they have been actively managed by the forestry industry for the past 150 years," the opposition spokeswoman on natural resources, Katrina Hodgkinson, said.
We also offered this analysis to southern forest groups:
Subject: redgum pr via Lake Cargelligo Re: [chipstop] Emailing: Riverina red gums get protection from logging - ABC News (Australian Broadcasting Corporation)I was wondering what the expert analysis would be of the redgum outcome. Notice Premier Keneally's people did PR choreography for this rural regional logging policy story by announcing water pipeline for Lake Cargelico which ran radio and tv last night.
Home | NSW Premier1 Mar 2010 ... $19 million pipeline to secure town water supplies for Lake Cargelligo. Premier Kristina Keneally and Federal Minister for Climate ChangeShe foreshadowed this over a month ago and got praise from The Greens for this (fair enough)This is surely her regime offsetting the backlash for literally any redgum forest protection by showing she cares for remote communities from Sydney - clever PR.
This cynical view of government choreography of regional rural stories seems to match with this expected reaction from local conservative authorities:
Riverina ABC reportage:Red gum park decision 'miserable' 3 March 2010Shires fear new parks to oust loggers 4 March 2010
How does that state government decision match up with the tough love of Minister Tony Burke we wondered, and with some chagrin: 6K cubic metres p.a. does seem quite low volumes compared to the east coast, but perhaps also quite high ecological effect for a generally dry environment with low growing rates?
Just now 9.30 am over the ABC radio 4 March 2010 we hear the next twist that 'a sawmill will close' in the Riverina having effectively decided to forego a 5 year logging future in the river redgums of the south west. So it seems Minister Burke's message of tough love has already had a further influence.
Here is text of environment groups below another file picture in this long running saga (as per ex premier 3 previous named in the banner above):
[2nd March 2010]
Groups Unite to Condemn Red Gum Back Down
Seven environment groups from across two States condemned the decision made today by the NSW Government to back down on the protection of River Red Gum wetlands.
"Despite yesterday’s rhetoric of new national park protection for Red Gum, the State Government has kept the best areas open to logging for five years” said Peter Cooper, Campaigner for The Wilderness Society Sydney.
“This is disastrous - these forests cannot sustain another five years of intensive logging damage."
"The Millewa forest, identified as an area significant enough for national park protection, will wait five years before it is protected. This is an exceedingly generous outcome for the forestry industry but a very poor one for conservation," said Mr Cooper.
“This was the decision to judge Premier Keneally’s environmental credentials and she has clearly failed. We are still to see any serious environmental outcomes in this term of Government and Premier Keneally has reversed the promises made for these forests.”
“Use of the NSW Environment Trust to continue logging is entirely inappropriate – vast funds will be spent without delivering the environmental outcomes which were promised.”
The weakness of the NSW red gum decision compares starkly against a similar decision to protect River Red Gum forests made by the Victorian Government in Dec 2008,” said Jonathan La Nauze, Friends of the Earth spokesperson.
“When Victoria protected 91,000 hectares of Red Gum it was described by environment groups as ‘one of the most significant conservation decisions in the state’s history’. The NSW decision today was described by the groups as an ‘empty shell’.”
“The Victorian Government delivered world class National Parks, including the full protection of the Barmah forest. Yesterday the NSW Government delivered a compromised outcome on the other side of the Murray River, with the unprecedented step of opening up half the Millewa to logging for the next five years before making it national park.”
“The Victorian Government delivered a jobs positive outcome which saw a net increase in employment for the region. The NSW Government has condemned the region to remaining stuck in the past by a protracted phase-out of industrial-scale logging and delaying the opportunity for new jobs creation”, said Mr La Nauze.
Activists dump Red Gum firewood on Premier Keneally’s doorstep
The Wilderness Society Sydney Inc.
25 February 2010
Activists from The Wilderness Society have today dumped a load of River Red Gum Firewood on the doorstep of Kristina Keneally’s Heffron office to highlight the destruction of the Murray River Red Gum Forests.
The firewood was accompanied by a banner reading “Kristina, your choice: River Red Gum National Parks or River Red Gum Firewood”. Today’s action launches a renewed campaign to communicate the need to protect the Murray River Red Gum Forests to the members of Ms Keneally’s electorate.
The Wilderness Society has become increasingly frustrated by the Premier’s lack of response to the December 2009 recommendations by the NSW Natural Resources Commission, which recommended the creation of over 100,000 hectares of new River Red Gum reserves.
A decision on creating new National Parks, as recommended, is currently before the Premier, from which the people of NSW will gauge her environmental credentials.
“Today’s action highlights the simple choice that Premier Keneally must make” said Peter Cooper, Campaigner for The Wilderness Society “She must chose between allowing the Murray River Red Gum Forests to be destroyed for firewood, or protecting them, as recommended by her own scientists”.
The NRC’s report confirmed the importance of the conservation values of these forests, as well as the environmental crisis the face – with up to 80% of trees stressed dead or dying in areas – and painted a damning picture of the impact of logging on the forests....................................
Will Keneally keep her Red Gum promise?
The Wilderness Society Sydney Inc.
2 March 2010
The National Parks Association of NSW and the Wilderness Society Sydney have this morning unfurled a large banner outside the Premier’s office to urge her to deliver today on her promise for large new Red Gum National Parks.
A large banner reading ‘Stop logging the Murray River Red Gum forests’ was strung between the trees outside Governor Macquarie Tower in Sydney. A decision on the future of the forests is expected today.
“This will be a chance to rescue Labor’s abysmal environmental record and put the Premier on the map for the environment” said Belinda Fairbrother, spokesperson for The Wilderness Society.
“The NSW Government has not delivered any major conservation outcomes in this term and delivering on their green promises is crucial to their integrity with the electorate.”
Since 2007 Labor has overseen windbacks in planning laws, massive expansions in coal mining and a blanket approval to a car rally in World Heritage rainforests. Hunting and tourist developments in National Parks are still on the agenda.
“Premier Keneally must create new National Parks across the River Red Gum Forests, as promised, if she wants to be able to present any environmental credentials to the people of NSW” said Carmel Flint, Spokesperson for the National Parks Association of NSW.
“The NSW Government needs to implement the decision of the independent umpire – the Natural Resources Commission. They mustn’t turn their back on the best technical advice.”
Environmentalists have expressed deep concern around the concept of ‘transitional parks’, where logging is phased out over a number of years. Millewa forest, the centrepiece of the National Parks system promised last year, is at risk of becoming damaged goods through ‘phase-out’ logging.
“The environmental crisis facing these forests is extreme, with over 80% of trees stressed, dead or dying in some areas.
The forests simply won’t cope with a transitional period that allows logging to continue – logging must end now if there is to be anything left worth placing into National Park” concluded Ms Flint.
Some screen shots above but excluding numbers for 3 days 9 and 10 Feb and 3rd March in usual period taken from 3rd of the month. Also taking into account Feb is a short month. While not being an expert on reading web stats it seems our pageviews are about 30K per month on a general upward trend, after a huge kick off early in the piece - perhaps a story about Simpson of Gallipoli
As we always say, it's not the numbers as the audience that interests us. We aim to reach the beltway in big media and big politics. Perhaps this is impertinent, overly optimistic, arrogant but you have to have a goal.
We got this nice feedback earlier this week:
Sent: Wednesday, March 03, 2010 9:44 AMSubject: Re: I called EP for PM/AM show and counselled them ....Gosh you are good, with a good memory and excellent research skills!Thanks for letting us know that Tom. I will pass this on to others as well.There's going to be more of this stuff too I am sure...Regards.......Electorate Officer for .......... MP.